Council backs big fire station

Approval is unanimous, despite concerns about an 80-foot tower.

By Lakiesha McGhee -- Bee Staff Writer
Published 2:15 am PDT Sunday, May 23, 2004

Plans to build a new fire station in Fair Oaks with an 80-foot communications tower received support Wednesday from the Fair Oaks Community Planning Advisory Council.

In a unanimous vote, the council recommended approval of the project to replace Fire Station No. 32 - at Hazel Avenue and Roediger Lane - with a 13,000-square-foot building.

The proposal will go to the Sacramento County Project Planning Commission for final action.

The project is part of a $40 million program by the Sacramento Metropolitan Fire District to replace eight outdated stations. The facilities do not meet current building codes and lack adequate communication systems for emergencies, officials said.

New stations also are planned at Greenback Lane and Kenneth Avenue in Orangevale and at Sunrise Boulevard and Douglas Road in Rancho Cordova.

The existing Fair Oaks station was built in 1964, district project manager Charles Horel said. The 3,900-square-foot building is on a 2-acre site that includes residential barracks set for demolition.

A 10-foot antenna atop the 25-foot-high building is part of an emergency communication system that is "hit and miss," Horel said. A taller tower would improve radio communication and provide better support for mobile data terminals used to send messages to police and fire vehicles, he said.

Many residents attending the meeting supported the fire district's plans, noting that a federal panel investigating the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks in New York City heard testimony last week about communication failures among emergency workers at the World Trade Center.

Other residents opposed the proposal for a taller tower, however.

One Roediger Lane resident said she was concerned that visual intrusion by the 80-foot tower would hurt her property value. Another suggested camouflaging the tower as a pine tree - a tactic used in other communities.

Horel said the district plans to screen the structure with redwood trees.

Council member Renee Taylor expressed concern that the county did not notify neighbors about the fire district's plans to build the tower.

"I have always struggled with putting a tower in someone's personal space," Taylor said.

Council member Joseph Maloney was less sympathetic to opponents' concerns.

"The next thing we'll be talking about is we have a fire station there, but we can't have fire trucks because they make too much noise," Maloney said.

While the council has frowned upon past proposals for cell towers in residential areas, members said Wednesday that the proposed emergency communication tower is a necessity.

In an effort to encourage a compromise, the council recommended that fire officials work with neighbors to determine if there is a less intrusive location for the tower.

"If you're going to build a state-of-the-art station, you need to do it right" council member Mary Klass Schultz said. "Any other way would be a waste of money."

The existing fire station would not be demolished until the new building is completed, Horel said. If the project is approved, the new fire station could be open by May 2006, he said.

 

Fire Capt. Jay Dougherty passes an unused building on the property of Station 32, one of several structures that would be demolished to make way for a new 13,000-square-foot facility. Some nearby residents opposed plans to build an 80-foot communications tower.

Sacramento Bee/Randall Benton

Capt. Jay Dougherty reads during his shift at Sacramento Metropolitan Fire District Station 32 in Fair Oaks last week. The Fair Oaks Community Planning Advisory Council has recommended approval of a proposal to replace the outdated facility with a new fire station.

 

Back to Relocation Page